When it comes to choosing a new roof, most homeowners narrow it down to two main options: metal roofs or asphalt shingles. Both materials are widely used across the country, but they offer dramatically different benefits in terms of cost, durability, appearance, and maintenance. So what is the difference between metal roof and shingles and how do you choose?
At Mountaintop Metal Roofing, we talk with homeowners every day who are trying to make the right long-term decision for their homes. Whether you’re replacing a worn-out asphalt shingle roof or exploring the idea of upgrading to metal for the first time, understanding the real differences between these two popular roofing options can help you feel confident about your investment.
Key Differences Between Metal Roofs and Shingles
Here are the main categories where metal roofing and asphalt shingles diverge—and what you should consider before making a decision:
- Lifespan and Durability
- Initial Cost vs. Long-Term Value
- Maintenance Requirements
- Energy Efficiency
- Environmental Impact
- Aesthetic Options
- Weight and Structural Requirements
- Installation Time and Labor
- Performance in Extreme Weather
- Warranty Coverage
- Resale Value and Home Perception
- Noise and Soundproofing
Obviously, there are a lot of things to consider when deciding between metal roofing and asphalt roofing material. Let’s dive right in!
1. Lifespan and Durability
Metal roofs typically last 40–70 years or more. In contrast, asphalt shingles generally last 15–25 years, depending on the quality of the shingles and the climate. Over time, shingles become brittle, curl, and lose granules—especially in high-heat or heavy-rain areas.
Metal roofing requires little maintenance to last for decades. It resists rot, mildew, pests, and cracking. It also performs better in areas prone to high winds, hail, or heavy snow loads.
If you’re thinking long term, metal wins hands down.
2. Initial Cost vs. Long-Term Value
It’s true that the cost of metal roof installation is typically higher than a shingle roof upfront. The shingles cost less per square foot, and asphalt roofs are generally quicker to install, which reduces labor expenses.
But that’s not the whole story.
Homes with metal roofs save money over time thanks to fewer repairs, less frequent replacement, and better energy efficiency. When you factor in the lifespan, cost effectiveness often shifts in favor of metal. You may pay more initially, but you’re likely paying once instead of multiple times.
3. Maintenance Requirements
Asphalt shingle roofs require routine maintenance—inspections, patching, moss removal, and eventual re-roofing. Shingles can blow off or degrade over time, especially in stormy or sunny climates.
Metal roofs generally require very little upkeep. Occasional rinsing and debris removal are usually all that’s needed. At Mountaintop, our premium materials and expert installation mean your roof won’t need constant attention.
4. Energy Efficiency
Metal roofing is far more energy efficient than asphalt. It reflects solar heat instead of absorbing it, helping to lower cooling costs during the summer months. Standing seam metal roofs can even be combined with vented systems or solar panels for extra efficiency.
Shingle roofs, on the other hand, tend to absorb heat. This can increase the strain on your HVAC system—especially in warmer climates or attics with poor ventilation.
If you’re looking to improve energy performance and reduce monthly bills, metal is a smart choice.
5. Environmental Impact
Metal roofs are often made from recycled materials, and they’re fully recyclable at the end of their lifespan. That makes them one of the most sustainable roofing options on the market.
By contrast, asphalt shingles contribute millions of tons of waste to landfills every year. And because they contain petroleum-based materials, they’re less eco-friendly to produce and dispose of.
For homeowners focused on green building, metal is the clear winner.
6. Aesthetic Options
Today’s metal roofing comes in a wide range of colors, profiles, and finishes—from sleek standing seam panels to traditional styles that mimic slate, tile, or even shake. You don’t have to sacrifice style for performance.
Shingle roofs offer a classic look, but with more limited aesthetic variety. While colors and textures exist, they can fade over time and tend to follow conventional patterns.
With homes with metal roofs, you get long-lasting curb appeal and a premium look that stands out.
7. Weight and Structural Requirements
Metal roofs are surprisingly lightweight, especially aluminum. This makes them ideal for both new construction and retrofits, often eliminating the need for structural reinforcement.
Asphalt shingles are heavier—especially when multiple layers are present. Older homes with existing shingle layers may require tear-off or reinforcement before adding more weight.
8. Installation Time and Labor
Shingle roofs are quicker to install, which can lower short-term labor costs. Roofing crews are typically well-versed in asphalt systems, and the materials are readily available.
Metal roof installation requires greater expertise, more specialized tools, and more attention to detail. While this increases installation time and cost, the trade-off is fewer problems down the road.
At Mountaintop Metal Roofing, our team specializes in getting it right the first time—so your roof performs flawlessly for decades.
9. Performance in Extreme Weather
Metal roofing excels in extreme weather. It sheds snow easily, resists high winds, and withstands hail better than most other materials. In fire-prone regions, it’s a top choice because of its non-combustible nature.
Asphalt roofs can be damaged more easily by wind uplift, hail impact, and heavy snow. Over time, water intrusion around damaged shingles can lead to mold and rot.
If you live in an area with intense seasonal swings, metal gives you peace of mind.
10. Warranty Coverage
Metal roofs typically come with stronger warranties—including lifetime, non-prorated, transferable warranties, offering real long-term protection and added resale value.
Shingle warranties often come with conditions: limited coverage, prorated terms, and exclusions based on weather, installation, or product failure.
11. Resale Value and Home Perception
Buyers increasingly recognize the value of metal roofing. It signals quality, energy savings, and low maintenance. That can increase the resale value of your home and make it more attractive on the market.
Shingle roofs don’t carry the same perception. If they’re nearing the end of their lifespan, they can even reduce home value and slow down a sale.
For homeowners planning to sell within the next 10–15 years, a metal roof can be a solid investment.
12. Noise and Soundproofing
One concern people raise about metal roofs is noise during rain or hail. But in reality, when installed over underlayment and attic insulation, they’re no louder than shingles.
Asphalt roofs have a natural dampening effect, but the sound difference is minimal when both systems are properly installed.
So while the myth of the “tin roof sound” persists, it’s not a dealbreaker—and modern systems easily account for it.
FAQs About Metal Roofs vs. Shingles
1. Is a metal roof better than shingles in the long run?
Yes. While the cost of metal roof installation is higher up front, the long-term savings in maintenance, replacement, and energy make it more cost-effective overall.
2. Do metal roofs make houses hotter or colder?
They actually help keep your home cooler. Metal reflects sunlight and can reduce cooling loads by up to 25% compared to dark asphalt roofs.
3. How much maintenance does a metal roof require?
Very little. Aside from clearing off leaves or debris and inspecting occasionally, metal roofing requires no routine patching, moss treatment, or shingle replacement.
4. Are metal roofs louder in rain?
Not when properly installed. The underlayment, attic space, and insulation between the roof and your living area dampen sound effectively.
5. Will switching to metal roofing increase installation costs significantly?
The increase in installation costs is real, but not unreasonable—especially considering the longevity and protection metal provides. Most homeowners see it as a one-time cost that pays off for decades.
Protect Your Home with a Roof That Lasts a Lifetime
If you’re weighing the pros and cons of metal roofs vs. shingles, one thing is clear: metal offers unmatched performance, energy savings, and peace of mind over the long term.
At Mountaintop Metal Roofing, we specialize in standing seam metal roofs and premium aluminum or copper profiles that enhance your home’s value and durability. With a lifetime, non-prorated, transferable warranty, it’s an investment you’ll never have to second-guess.
Get your free estimate today or reach out to our team to learn more about how metal roofing can transform your home. We’re here to answer your questions, walk you through the options, and deliver a roofing solution that stands the test of time.